Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree
4.7

Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree

Amy Taylor's profile
By Amy Taylor4/26/2025

When I heard that Elden Ring was getting a full expansion, I could not wait to jump back into the Lands Between. The world of Elden Ring had already gripped me for hundreds of hours, and the promise of a new realm to explore was irresistible. Shadow of the Erdtree did not just meet my expectations, it reignited my sense of wonder and adventure in ways I honestly did not think were still possible for a game I knew so well.

From the moment I set foot in the Land of Shadow, I knew I was in for something special. This expansion does not just bolt on extra content; it feels like an essential and deeply connected extension of the world we all fell in love with. Whether I was cautiously picking my way through haunted ruins or preparing for a towering boss fight, Shadow of the Erdtree constantly reminded me why FromSoftware's games have such a special place in my heart.

A Journey into the Land of Shadow

From the first steps into the Land of Shadow, the game's atmosphere hits with full force. It is eerie, it is grand, and it constantly nudges you to keep pushing deeper. Every corner hides new secrets, with environmental storytelling woven into the crumbling architecture and forgotten paths. The verticality of the world made exploration feel exhilarating again. I spent entire sessions just trying to figure out how to reach a far-off ledge or hidden area that I caught a glimpse of from miles away.

Miquella’s story thread runs through the heart of the expansion, adding a whole new layer to Elden Ring’s sprawling lore. True to FromSoftware’s style, much of the storytelling is indirect, leaving players to piece together events from cryptic dialogue, hidden items, and environmental clues. I found myself pulling up old notes and theories from the original game, feeling genuinely excited as the mysteries of Miquella’s journey slowly unfolded around me.

Combat and Challenge

Shadow of the Erdtree is not here to make life easy. Every enemy feels handcrafted to test the player’s limits, and every boss demands focus, strategy, and creativity. One fight against Messmer the Impaler had me sweating bullets as I learned the timing of his brutal flame attacks, inching closer to victory with each painful lesson. The sheer difficulty of some encounters reminded me of my first brutal introduction to Souls games, and I loved every second of it.

New weapons, armor, and spells add even more ways to approach combat. I experimented with a new heavy flail build that turned out to be perfect for staggering the hulking knights of the expansion. The freedom to adapt and the encouragement to rethink strategies kept the experience fresh and rewarding. No victory came easily, but every win felt like a true triumph earned through perseverance and clever play.

Visual and Audio Design

The visual splendor of Shadow of the Erdtree cannot be overstated. The landscapes are breathtakingly diverse, from mist-choked swamps to towering, luminous ruins. The game's use of light and weather gives every area its own unique mood. One minute you are standing beneath a sky streaked with unnatural colors, and the next you are creeping through pitch-black ruins with only your torch to keep the darkness at bay.

The sound design is equally masterful. The soundtrack swells during climactic moments without ever becoming intrusive. The subtle hum of the wind, the clinking of distant chains, and the whispering echoes of forgotten places build a world that feels alive and steeped in history. Every sound, whether in battle or during quiet exploration, helps to ground you more deeply in this haunted, majestic land.

Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Expansive new areas with rich vertical exploration and hidden secrets.
  • Deepened lore that ties beautifully into the original game’s story.
  • Challenging and rewarding combat encounters that demand mastery.
  • Stunning visuals and atmospheric sound design that elevate immersion.

Cons:

  • High difficulty may intimidate some players who prefer a more casual experience.
  • Occasional performance hiccups depending on platform and hardware.
  • Cryptic progression paths may cause confusion without outside guidance.
New Secrets

In conclusion, Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree is everything I could have hoped for in an expansion. It respects the incredible foundation of Elden Ring while building something that feels bold, fresh, and absolutely essential. It reminded me why I fell in love with the Lands Between in the first place, and it gave me even more reasons to keep exploring, fighting, and uncovering its endless mysteries.